42A New York Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this 1880s traditional home was completely restored in 2022, blending historic charm with modern comforts. Thoughtfully updated, the home retains its original character while incorporating today's must-have amenities. Original hardwood floors throughout with most windows updated. Step into the inviting front foyer, where the spacious living room to the left stretches from the front to the rear of the home, featuring walls of windows and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. To the right, the dining room, adorned with original stained glass, opens to a recently installed kitchen with Bertazzoni appliances, custom cabinets, and a convenient laundry room. Toward the rear of the home offering privacy, is a guest en-suite bedroom. Upstairs, the second floor features a primary en-suite bedroom on the north side of the house, complete with original arched doors that open onto a private balcony and a newly renovated bathroom. The hallway leads to a third bedroom, a full bath, and a generously sized fourth bedroom. The lower level includes an unfinished basement and garage with direct access to Meadow Lane. Situated in a prime location across from the Heights flagpole and just a short distance from ferry, the beach club and golf club, this timeless Heights home is a rare opportunity. Make it yours today! Heights annual HOA fees are$5,928.95, Additional information: Interior Features:Guest Quarters,Lr/Dr