OneKey® MLS
  • Buy
  • Rent
  • Commercial
  • Find an Agent
  • Fair Housing Notices
  • Language
    Price range
    $
    $
    Bedrooms
    Bathrooms
    Home type
    Square feet
    Lot size
    Heating
    Cooling
    Parking spots
    Garage
    Basement
    Year built
    Max HOA
    Down payment assistanceDown payment assistance
    Tours
    View
    More amenities
    1 home
    1 home available
    Closed Feb 11, 2025
    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    $3,500,000
    3beds
    4bath
    3,225sqft
    acres
    House for Sale

    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
    1 - 1 of 1 results
    Copyright © 2025 OneKey® MLS LLC
    Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
    Equal opportunity
    Membio
    OneKey® MLS
    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Closed Feb 11, 2025
    $3,500,000
    3beds
    4full,half bath
    3,225sqft
    acres

    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    City/Town:Shelter Island   Post Office: Shelter Island     

    House for Sale by Michael BrennanDouglas Elliman Real Estate.

    Data checked -. Listing last updated 42 days ago.
    1. Overview
    2. Details
    3. More 

    Limited opportunity for this special property! Unique Shelter Island opportunity to find 8.5 acres with unobstructed scenic views that will leave you speechless. This classic property is currently being utilized as a horse farm, with a 3 bedroom main house, 3 stall horse stables, a barn and a pool house/garage with studio and full bath above. The main house features 3 en-suite bedrooms, kitchen, living room, dining room, a den/sunroom off the primary suite and a large mudroom with laundry. The second floor features two large en-suite bedrooms and a bonus room. With all this land, this is a great opportunity to reimagine the current home or to bring your architect and create your own dream. Located in "C Residential" zone, the possibilities are endless, with subdivision opportunities and full development rights. This property and all of its surrounding land promise a lifestyle of unparalleled beauty, adventure, and tranquility., Additional information: Interior Features:Guest Quarters

    Details
      Property type
    Residential
      Year built
    1985
      Heating
    Forced Air, Propane
      Cooling
    Central Air, Wall Unit(s)
      Total rooms
    14
      Garage
    No
      City/Town
    Shelter Island
      Post Office
    Shelter Island
      Parking spots
    -
    L3560589
    MLS ID
    Closed
    Status
    Feb 11, 2025
    Closed
      Laundry features
      Flooring
    Hardwood
      Fireplace
    No
      Pets allowed
      Architectural Style
    Farm House
      View
    Panoramic
    Interior features
    Formal Dining, Master Downstairs, Primary Bathroom, Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s)
    Exterior features
    Lot features
    Part Wooded
    Appliances included
    Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Oil Water Heater
    Construction materials
    Frame, Shingle Siding
    Monthly taxes
    $966
    Yearly taxes
    $11,587
    Community Features
    Fitness Center
    School district
    Shelter Island
    Schools
    Shelter Island School
    Senior community
    No
    Common Charges
    -
    Maintenance
    -
    Additional Fees
    -
    Open Houses
    In-Person
    No upcoming in-person open houses
    Virtual
    No upcoming virtual open houses
    Contact Agent
    Michael Brennan
    Michael Brennan
    Real Estate Salesperson, Douglas Elliman Real Estate
    Direct Number 
     
    Location
    Enter traffic circle on St Mary's Rd and taker a left into the property.
    For Sale Nearby
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Recently Sold
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    Closed
    $
    beds
    sqft
    acres

    undefined

    Listing by:
    44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, is a 3 bedroom, 4 bathroom, 3225 sqft. Single Family Residence built in 1985. This property is currently available for sale and was listed on OneKey® MLS on Invalid date. The MLS# for this Single Family Residence is MLS# L3560589.
    Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
    Copyright ©2025
    BESbswy