Price range
$
Any Price
$1K
$1.2K
$1.4K
$1.6K
$1.8K
$2K
$2.2K
$2.4K
$2.6K
$2.8K
–
$
$3K
$3.5K
$4K
$4.5K
$5K
$5.5K
$6K
$6.5K
$7K
$7.5K
Any Price
Bedrooms
Bathrooms
Home type
Square feet
–
Lot size
–
Heating
Cooling
Parking spots
Garage
Basement
Year built
–
Max HOA
Apply with RentSpree 
Tours
View
More amenities
1 home
1 home available
5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Price Increased $11,000
$18,000
3beds
3bath
1,675sqft
0.58acres
House for Rent
5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
1 - 1 of 1 results
NYS Fair Housing NoticeNYS Reasonable Accommodation & Modification NoticePrivacy PolicyTerms of UseADADMCAReal Estate SitemapReal Estate Agent & Office Directory
400 Broadhollow Road, Suite 5, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Copyright © 2025 OneKey® MLS LLC
Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
NYSuffolk CountyShelter Island119645 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
NY/Suffolk County/Shelter Island/11964/5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 119645 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Price Increased $11,000
$18,000 $11,000
3beds
3full,–half bath
1,675sqft
0.58acres
5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964
City/Town:Shelter Island Post Office: Shelter Island
House for Rent by Michael Brennan, Douglas Elliman Real Estate.
Data checked -. Listing last updated 25 days ago.
- Overview
- Details
- More
Open plan beach house with superb water views located in the highly sought after Montclair Colony. Centrally located near markets and many conveniences, there is much to adore in this home. Open plan living room with sunroom, dining and eat in kitchen. This home offers two bedrooms with two full baths and another bedroom with a full bath over the two car garage. In addition the master bedroom has a walk-in closet. Come see the private large deck, enclosed sunporch and gunite pool. Convenient to town beaches and other popular destinations. There is water access at the end of the street. MD-LD $70K June $18K July $25K August $30K Yr - $7K per month ($84K annual)
Details
Property type
Residential Lease
Year built
1951
Heating
Baseboard
Cooling
Central Air
Total rooms
9
Garage
Yes (2 space)
City/Town
Shelter Island
Post Office
Shelter Island
Parking spots
-
823843
MLS ID
Active
Status
/
On Market Date
Laundry features
–
Flooring
–
Fireplace
No
Pets allowed
Call
Architectural Style
Ranch
View
–
Interior features
First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Built-in Features, High Speed Internet, Primary Bathroom, Open Floorplan, Open Kitchen, Walk-In Closet(s)
Exterior features
–
Lot features
–
Appliances included
Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Water Heater, ENERGY STAR Qualified Appliances, Freezer, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
Construction materials
Advanced Framing Technique
Monthly taxes
-
Yearly taxes
-
Community Features
-
School district
Shelter Island
Schools
Contact Agent, Shelter Island School
Senior community
No
Common Charges
-
Maintenance
-
Additional Fees
-
Open Houses
In-Person
No upcoming in-person open houses
VirtualNo upcoming virtual open houses
Contact Agent
Location
For Lease Nearby
27 Tupper Avenue, Medford, NY 11763
$575,000
3beds
2bath
1,099sqft
–acres
House for Rent
27 Tupper Avenue, Medford, NY 11763
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
43 West Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
$695,000
5beds
3bath
–sqft
–acres
House for Rent
43 West Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc
68 San Rafael Avenue, Holbrook, NY 11741
Down Payment Help
$748,000
4beds
2.5bath
2,278sqft
–acres
House for Rent
Down Payment Help68 San Rafael Avenue, Holbrook, NY 11741
Listing by: Shawn Michael Realty
59 West Shore Road, Oakdale, NY 11769
$592,200
4beds
3bath
–sqft
–acres
House for Rent
59 West Shore Road, Oakdale, NY 11769
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
31 Periwinkle Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
$95,000
2beds
1bath
1,000sqft
–acres
Residential
31 Periwinkle Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc
103 Norman Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
$730,000
6beds
2bath
2,682sqft
–acres
House for Rent
103 Norman Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
142 Greenbelt Parkway, Holbrook, NY 11741
$660,000
3beds
2bath
–sqft
–acres
House for Rent
142 Greenbelt Parkway, Holbrook, NY 11741
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
132 Patchogue Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
$425,000
2beds
1bath
660sqft
–acres
House for Rent
132 Patchogue Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
44 Ticonderoga, Bohemia, NY 11716
$217,000
2beds
2bath
900sqft
–acres
Residential
44 Ticonderoga, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
154 Mcneil Street, Sayville, NY 11782
$799,999
4beds
2bath
2,212sqft
–acres
House for Rent
154 Mcneil Street, Sayville, NY 11782
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Recently Leased
27 Tupper Avenue, Medford, NY 11763
Closed Mar 21
$575,000
3beds
2bath
9,583sqft
–acres
House for Rent
27 Tupper Avenue, Medford, NY 11763
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
43 West Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Closed Mar 21
$695,000
5beds
3bath
–sqft
–acres
House for Rent
43 West Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc
68 San Rafael Avenue, Holbrook, NY 11741Down Payment Help
Closed Mar 20
$748,000
4beds
2.5bath
10,019sqft
–acres
House for Rent
Down Payment Help68 San Rafael Avenue, Holbrook, NY 11741
Listing by: Shawn Michael Realty
59 West Shore Road, Oakdale, NY 11769
Closed Mar 19
$592,200
4beds
3bath
10,890sqft
–acres
House for Rent
59 West Shore Road, Oakdale, NY 11769
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
31 Periwinkle Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Closed Mar 19
$95,000
2beds
1bath
–sqft
–acres
Residential
31 Periwinkle Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc
103 Norman Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Closed Mar 19
$730,000
6beds
2bath
10,890sqft
–acres
House for Rent
103 Norman Drive, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
142 Greenbelt Parkway, Holbrook, NY 11741
Closed Mar 19
$660,000
3beds
2bath
11,326sqft
–acres
House for Rent
142 Greenbelt Parkway, Holbrook, NY 11741
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
132 Patchogue Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Closed Mar 18
$425,000
2beds
1bath
11,761sqft
–acres
House for Rent
132 Patchogue Avenue, Patchogue, NY 11772
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
44 Ticonderoga, Bohemia, NY 11716
Closed Mar 18
$217,000
2beds
2bath
1,500sqft
–acres
Residential
44 Ticonderoga, Bohemia, NY 11716
Listing by: Signature Premier Properties
154 Mcneil Street, Sayville, NY 11782
Closed Mar 17
$799,999
4beds
2bath
8,712sqft
–acres
House for Rent
154 Mcneil Street, Sayville, NY 11782
Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate
5 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11964, is a 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 1675 sqft. Single Family Residence built in 1951.
This property is currently available for rent and was listed on OneKey® MLS on Invalid date.
The MLS# for this Single Family Residence is MLS# 823843.
Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals.
Copyright ©2025